Quran PonderAll surahsOpen in the app

Surah At-Tawbah, ayah 76 (9:76)

Surah At-Tawbah · Madani · ayah 76 of 129 · in Broken pledges and mocked givers

Ponder At-Tawbah 9:76 in the app →

فَلَمَّآ ءَاتَىٰهُم مِّن فَضْلِهِۦ بَخِلُوا۟ بِهِۦ وَتَوَلَّوا۟ وَّهُم مُّعْرِضُونَ

“But when He gave them from His bounty, they were stingy with it and turned away while they refused.”

Saheeh International

What does Surah At-Tawbah 9:76 mean?

Allah met the condition word for word; they answered with a closed hand, a turned back, and a heart that had learned to look away.

Reflections

He kept a bargain He never needed

Set the two ayat side by side. The vow said: la-in ātānā min faḍlihi, if He gives us of His bounty. This ayah answers: fa-lammā ātāhum min faḍlihi, then when He gave them of His bounty. The same verb, the same phrase, almost letter for letter.

The repetition is the point. Allah met their condition exactly. He was under no obligation to accept their terms at all. Faḍl, the lexicons say, is a gift the giver was not bound to give. Yet the One who owes no one anything fulfilled His side to the word. They were the ones who failed.

That should shrink a particular kind of pride in us. When money comes, the ego writes its own account of where it came from. My planning. My contacts. My hours. A man starts a small van-hire business and calls himself self-made on every profile. His mother remembers the night he sat on the prayer mat asking Allah to let the bank say yes.

The ayah does not let that account stand. Whatever arrived came min faḍlihi: from His overflow, given on His terms, at His timing. Every one of us is living inside a condition Allah has already met. The health we asked for in a hospital corridor. The job we asked for before an interview. The child we asked for for years.

There is relief in this as well as rebuke. If the gift was never earned, it was never ours to grip so tightly. A hand that knows it is holding a loan opens more easily than a hand that thinks it is holding a prize.

The humbling question is not whether He kept His word. It is whether we have kept ours since.

A hand, a back, and a sideways stance

The ayah describes the failure in three movements, and they go deeper as they go.

Bakhilū bihi: they were stingy with it. The hand closes. Wa-tawallaw: and they turned away. The whole body turns its back. Wa-hum muʿriḍūn: and they are people who turn aside. The last phrase is not a verb in the past. It is a description of what they now are, a settled posture.

A theological commentary reads the three as three faults. Withholding what was owed. Turning from the covenant they made. Turning from Allah's commands altogether. The lexicons give iʿrāḍ a vivid picture. The root is breadth, the side of a thing. To turn aside is to show someone only your side, like a stick laid across the mouth of a jar.

This is how avoidance usually grows. Think of a man who borrowed money from a friend at the mosque and has not repaid it. First he simply does not mention it. Then he starts leaving Jumuʿa by the side door. Within a year he prays at a different mosque across town. He never decided to cut his friend off. Each step just felt like the easiest thing that day.

The same slide happens between a person and a promise to Allah. First the hand closes on one payment. Then the eye starts skipping the charity appeal and the ayah that stings. Finally the whole subject is something one simply does not face.

The ayah's order offers a warning and a way back. Catch it at the hand, before it reaches the back. A closed hand can be opened today. A sideways stance takes much longer to turn.

Stingy with more than money

Mention stinginess and most people picture a wallet that stays shut. The ayah's men were stingy with money, certainly. But the word is wider than that, and the wider meaning catches far more of us.

The lexicons give no physical picture for this root. They define it simply: holding possessions back from where they rightly belong. A theological commentary sharpens it. In the language of the law, bukhl is withholding what is owed. It is not failing to give an extra. It is keeping back what someone has a right to.

Now look at a narration that stretches the word in an unexpected direction. Al-Tirmidhi records it, grading it ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ gharīb (good, authentic, with a single chain). The Prophet ﷺ said: the miser is the one before whom I am mentioned, and he does not send blessings on me.

A few words, costing nothing, are owed. Holding them back is bukhl.

Once you see that, stinginess turns up everywhere. A father pays every bill for his son without complaint, and has not once said 'I am proud of you'. A wife thanks the waiter but not her husband. A manager pays salaries on the dot and withholds the one sentence of credit his team has earned. All of them are generous on paper and misers in what is owed.

The ayah's men withheld a due that was written in coins. Most of our withholding is written in words, attention and thanks. Those debts are just as real, and usually much easier to pay. Start with the cheapest due of all: when you hear his name, ﷺ, send the blessing.

When the promised share becomes payable

The most dangerous moment for a promise is not when it is made. It is when it becomes payable. That moment has a word in this ayah: fa-lammā, then when.

The owner of a small design studio tells her team in a lean winter: land this account and everyone shares in the first year's profit. They work late for three months. The account comes in. Then the language shifts. Cash flow. Reinvestment. Next quarter. Nobody is told no. The share simply never arrives.

She did not mean to deceive them. But the next time she asks the team to stay late, no one does. Something in the studio has quietly turned its back.

That is the leadership lesson folded into this ayah. People judge a leader less by what she promises than by what she does at fa-lammā (but when). A promise kept on the day it falls due, without being chased, builds more loyalty than any speech. A promise slid past that day teaches everyone that her words carry a hidden condition.

The commentaries describe the ayah's men as having received what they asked for, and then withholding what they had pledged. Withholding at that moment did not only break a promise. It revealed what the promise had been worth from the start.

The same is true at home. A father promises his daughter a day out of her choosing if she finishes her hifz of a juz. She finishes it on a busy week. Whether he clears the Saturday tells her more about promises than any lesson on honesty.

If you lead anyone, a family, a team, a mosque committee, look for your fa-lammā (but when) moments. Write down what you have promised. When the condition arrives, pay first and explain later.

Careful with money, or closed around it?

A fair objection rises here. Once people have money, they become careful with it. They have children, a rent, a future to plan. Isn't some of what this ayah calls stinginess simply growing up?

The commentaries help draw the line. A theological commentary argues that what these men withheld was not a voluntary extra. It was what the law already required of wealth like theirs, which their vow had only made more vivid. Another reads their pledge as charity plus everything good people do with money: keeping ties with family, spending in the way of Allah.

So the ayah is not condemning a savings account. It condemns a closed hand around what is owed, and a back turned on a promise.

A nurse on night shifts is saving for her children's future. Some evenings she wonders whether she has become mean. One test settles it. Does her plan have a line in it for others? Her budget does: a fixed amount every month goes to a widow she knows, before anything else is saved. She is careful, not closed.

Prudence plans how to give. Stinginess plans how not to. Prudence still pays what is owed when it falls due. Stinginess finds a fresh reason each time.

What remains open is the honest work of applying that line. Only you know whether your caution is planning or hiding. The ayah's three verbs are a good test. If your hand is careful but your back has not turned, you are probably still on the right side of it.

Grateful for yourself

Bakhilū bihi: they were stingy with it. With what? With the very bounty that had just been given. The little word bihi points straight back to faḍlihi. They held tight to something that had been placed in their hands a moment before.

The Quran tells another story of a gift arriving, and a very different response. The throne of the Queen of Sheba was set down before Sulaymān (as) in the blink of an eye. He did not say: look what I have achieved. He said: hādhā min faḍli rabbī, this is from the bounty of my Lord. It is to test me, whether I will be grateful or ungrateful (27:40).

The same phrase, min faḍl, sits at the centre of both scenes. One man saw a test and passed it. The others saw a possession and closed their hands.

Sulaymān's next words answer any doubt about who gains. Whoever is grateful is grateful only for himself. Whoever is ungrateful, my Lord is free of need, Most Generous. Allah lost nothing when these men held back. They lost the chance to be the kind of people Sulaymān was.

A young graduate's first salary lands on a Thursday night. Before she spends a penny of it, she sends a portion to her old Quran teacher's school. It is a small way of saying hādhā min faḍli rabbī out loud. The money is still hers. But the first move of her hand was to open, not to close.

A common misreading

Often heard: Stinginess means not giving extra money to charity.

Closer to the ayah: Bukhl is withholding what is owed, and the Prophet ﷺ applied it even to withheld words: the miser is the one who hears his name and sends no blessing.

Words to know

بَخِلُوا۟ bakhilū · the root b-kh-l

They were stingy. The lexicons define the root as the opposite of generosity: holding possessions back from where they rightly belong. A theological commentary notes that in the law's usage it means withholding what is due, not declining to give an extra.

Questions to sit with

Live it today

Pay one overdue debt today, in money or in words: the thanks, the credit, the blessing on the Prophet ﷺ when his name is said.

Echoes in the Quran

Come back to this ayah when you feel...

when you have given your word · when you take people for granted · after a success · when blessings feel ordinary · when you lead others

The classical tafsir of this ayah

Tafsir al-Jalalayn · Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) · Tafsir al-Tabari (abridged) · Tafsir al-Qurtubi (abridged) · Tafsir al-Sa'di

Read the whole surah

A proclamation at Mina, and the road home: a reflection on all of Surah At-Tawbah, from its first ayah to its last.

Ponder At-Tawbah 9:76 in the app →

In the app: the Mushaf, every word with its root, side-by-side tafsir, and your own private reflections. Free, no account, works offline.