Quran PonderAll surahsOpen in the app

Surah Al-Hijr, ayah 10 (15:10)

Surah Al-Hijr · Makki · ayah 10 of 99 · in The mockers and the kept Reminder

Ponder Al-Hijr 15:10 in the app →

وَلَقَدْ أَرْسَلْنَا مِن قَبْلِكَ فِى شِيَعِ ٱلْأَوَّلِينَ

“And We had certainly sent [messengers] before you, [O Muḥammad], among the sects of the former peoples.”

Saheeh International

What does Surah Al-Hijr 15:10 mean?

Messengers were sent before, not to distant crowds but into the midst of settled factions, living among the very people who would laugh at them.

Reflections

Sent in, not sent to

The ayah could have said that messengers were sent to the earlier peoples. It says they were sent fī, in them. 'We sent before you among the factions of the earlier peoples.'

One classical commentator pauses on that small preposition. Sending a messenger in a people, he explains, means making him a messenger in their midst. They could then follow him in everything he did and everything he left. 'To' would not show that. Another view he records says the choice of 'in' signals a deeper settling among them.

So the messengers did not call from a distance, deliver a document and leave. They lived in the street. People saw how they bought and sold, how they treated their families, how they took an insult. The message arrived with a life attached, under observation, every day.

This is the hardest form of leadership, and the most persuasive. A manager who sends memos to the warehouse floor has been sent 'to' it. A manager who works a night shift on it has been sent 'in' it. The second is exposed, because every inconsistency shows. But the second is also the one people truly follow, because they have watched the instruction being lived.

It is also why the mockery in the next ayah cuts so deep. They did not mock a stranger. They mocked someone they had seen up close, whose honesty they knew. That says more about the mockers than about the man. A stranger can be dismissed as unknown. A neighbour of forty years can only be dismissed by refusing what you yourself have seen.

For anyone carrying faith into a family, an office or a friendship, the preposition is a quiet instruction. You are not sent to these people. You are placed among them. Your words will be weighed against your Tuesday afternoons. Let them be worth weighing.

Groups where everyone stands behind everyone else

Shiyaʿ is the plural of shīʿa. Many readers today hear only a modern label in that word. In the Quran's Arabic it is older and wider. The commentators define it as people gathered together whose word is agreed: a faction settled on one way and one creed.

The root carries a picture. The Arabs said they shayyaʿa a traveller when they walked out with him to send him on his road. A brave man was called mushayyaʿ, as though someone always stood behind him. One classical commentator explains the name from a related sense. A shīʿa is people who follow one another, until they come to resemble one another.

So the messengers were not sent to lone individuals weighing evidence in private. They were sent into groups where everyone already stood behind everyone else. That is the hardest audience there is. A lone listener can change his mind quietly. A man inside a faction must change it in front of the people who back him, and may lose them.

The pattern is easy to recognise now. Picture a family group chat where one cousin has started praying regularly. Nobody argues with her. Someone posts a joke instead, and three laughing replies follow within a minute. No one in that chat has thought about prayer at all. Each has simply stood behind the others.

This is why so much resistance to truth is not really intellectual. It is social. The question is rarely whether it is right. It is who will still stand behind me if I say yes.

The ayah does not sneer at that fear. It names it, and the next ayat show where the factions ended. Before you laugh along with your own group, it is worth asking whether you are thinking, or only being backed.

Five reasons a messenger is laughed at

When a messenger arrives, why does laughter come so quickly? One classical commentator, explaining this passage, lists the causes. They are uncomfortable to read, because they still describe us.

First, people find it heavy to take on acts of obedience and to hold back from pleasures they enjoy. Second, the messenger calls them to leave what they are used to, and leaving the familiar is hard on human nature. Third, a messenger is to be followed and served. That is hard on people used to being followed themselves. Fourth, a messenger may be poor, with no wealth, rank or supporters, and the comfortable find it heavy to follow such a man. The fifth, he says, is the root of the rest. Allah leaves them to themselves, and the pull towards denial is never lifted from their hearts.

Read the first four slowly and they stop sounding ancient. A man is invited by a quiet colleague to a short study circle after the Friday prayer. In the car afterwards, he makes a joke about it to the others. Ask him why, and he would say it is not his thing. Underneath the joke sit three of the four. It would cost him his Friday evenings. It would mean changing habits he has had since university. And it would mean sitting before a younger man in an ill-fitting suit, when he is a department head.

Mockery is often a way of declining without admitting the real reason. It turns 'this would cost me' into 'this is ridiculous'.

The fifth cause should leave no one feeling safe. It is why the believer keeps asking Allah not to leave him to himself. The laughter of the old factions is no museum piece. It is a set of pressures every heart still feels, and only His help lifts them.

A nation, a faction, a village

The commentators give shiyaʿ (factions) in this ayah three different sizes.

One early authority says it means nations: whole peoples of the past. Another early voice says factions: parties and groups within those peoples. A third says it means towns and villages.

All three can stand, and together they say something. Messengers came at every scale on which people live. To a nation with kings and armies. To a faction inside a nation, with its own loyalties. To a village where everyone knew everyone's grandfather.

The call meets each person at the size of their own world. For some, the decisive pressure is national: what my country, my culture or my generation calls normal. For others it is a faction: my profession, my circle, the people I want to be counted among. For many it is the village: the street, the family, the aunt whose opinion follows every decision.

A young man moves from a small town to a big city for work. At home the pressure on his faith was the village. Everyone would know if he missed the mosque, and everyone would know if he went too often. In the city nobody knows him, and the pressure changes size. Now it is the office crowd, who eat out together every Thursday and wonder why he slips away before the late prayer. The test followed him. Only its scale changed. One evening he notices he has started making excuses before anyone has asked for one. That is the faction at work, without a word being said.

That is worth knowing about yourself. Which size is your shīʿa: the nation, the faction or the village? Whichever it is, a messenger was once sent into exactly that size of world, and met exactly that kind of resistance. What you face is something the Quran already saw coming.

The hand on the shoulder before the history

Look at the order of the passage. First comes the ayah before this one: 'It is We who sent down the Reminder, and We are its guardians' (15:9). Only then comes this one: messengers were sent before you, and they were mocked.

The commentators agree this ayah is consolation for the Prophet ﷺ. His people were treating him exactly as earlier peoples treated theirs. One concise commentary puts it plainly: you are no novelty among the messengers, in your people's denial of you.

But comfort drawn from other people's trouble can feel thin. Telling a hurting person that others have had it worse rarely helps. It can even sound like 'stop complaining'.

The order of these ayat avoids that. Before a word is said about earlier messengers, the Prophet ﷺ is told who stands behind his message, and that it is kept. Only then is he shown the long line he belongs to. Nuh, Hud, Salih, Shuʿayb and Musa all stand in that line, and each was met with scorn by the people he was sent to. The history does not replace the support. It comes after it, and leans on it.

Picture a newly qualified teacher at the end of a dreadful first week. One class has laughed at her for five days. Her head of department finds her in the car park. He does not begin with 'every new teacher goes through this'. He begins with 'I've got you, and you are not going anywhere'. Once she has heard that, he tells her about his own first term, and the afternoon a chair was thrown. Now the story helps, because it is not standing in for him.

This is how the Quran comforts here, and it is a good order to borrow. When someone comes to you hurt, begin with the hand on the shoulder. Then tell the history.

A common misreading

Often heard: Shiyaʿ, the plural of shīʿa, is heard only as a modern sectarian name.

Closer to the ayah: In the Quran's Arabic a shīʿa is any following or faction whose members back one another and agree on one way; here it means the nations and parties of old.

Words to know

شِيَعِ shiyaʿi · the root sh-y-ʿ

Plural of shīʿa. The commentators explain it as nations, as factions agreed on one way, or, in one early view, as towns. The root joins two ideas: backing a person up, as when you walk a traveller out on his road, and spreading, as news spreads. A shīʿa is a following that leans towards someone and spreads out from him. The Quran uses the word for groups of every kind, good and bad.

أَرْسَلْنَا arsalnā · the root r-s-l

We sent. The verb has no object in the Arabic: 'messengers' is left unsaid. The commentators explain that the sending itself points to who was sent, so the word could be dropped. The effect is that the sentence rests on the Sender rather than on a list of names. It also opens with wa-laqad, an emphatic 'and indeed', making the statement firm.

Questions to sit with

Live it today

The next time someone brings you a hurt, begin with your support before any story of others who had it worse. And notice once this week when you laughed along only because your group did.

Come back to this ayah when you feel...

when doing good meets resistance · when someone comes to you shaken · when you are mocked for your faith · when you lead others

The classical tafsir of this ayah

Tafsir al-Jalalayn · Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) · Tafsir al-Tabari (abridged) · Tafsir al-Qurtubi (abridged) · Tafsir al-Sa'di

Read the whole surah

The line that ran past the wall: a reflection on all of Surah Al-Hijr, from its first ayah to its last.

Ponder Al-Hijr 15:10 in the app →

In the app: the Mushaf, every word with its root, side-by-side tafsir, and your own private reflections. Free, no account, works offline.