Surah At-Tawbah, ayah 90 (9:90)
Surah At-Tawbah · Madani · ayah 90 of 129 · in The excused and the excuse-makers
Ponder At-Tawbah 9:90 in the app →وَجَآءَ ٱلْمُعَذِّرُونَ مِنَ ٱلْأَعْرَابِ لِيُؤْذَنَ لَهُمْ وَقَعَدَ ٱلَّذِينَ كَذَبُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَرَسُولَهُۥ ۚ سَيُصِيبُ ٱلَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا۟ مِنْهُمْ عَذَابٌ أَلِيمٌ
“And those with excuses among the bedouins came to be permitted [to remain], and they who had lied to Allāh and His Messenger sat [at home]. There will strike those who disbelieved among them a painful punishment.”
Saheeh International
What does Surah At-Tawbah 9:90 mean?
Some came with excuses, some did not even come; a lie told to Allah fools only the liar, and seats him.
Reflections
The lie that makes you sit down
For three years a man has told his friends he is about to start memorising the Quran. He has the app, the notebook and a teacher's number saved. Each time someone asks, he describes the plan in more detail. Somewhere in the third year he notices that describing the plan has replaced doing it. The talking feels like progress. He has not memorised a single new page.
The ayah joins two verbs that we rarely put side by side. Qaʿada, they sat. Alladhīna kadhabū Allāha wa-rasūlahu, those who lied to Allah and His Messenger. The commentaries say the lie was their claim to faith. They said 'we believe', and the claim had nothing under it.
One classical writer on the heart read this ayah with unusual care. He quotes it in a passage on what lying does to the liar. A lie, he says, first spoils your own picture of things. You start to see what does not exist as if it did, and what does exist as if it did not. Then it spreads from the tongue to the limbs. And then comes its penalty. Allah, he writes, punishes the liar by making him sit, holding him back from the very things that would benefit him. The truthful person is helped to rise to what is good for him in this world and the next.
Read that way, qaʿada (sat back) is not only what they did. It is what the lie did to them. The claim of faith with no faith under it became a weight in the legs.
This is uncomfortable, because the mechanism is so ordinary. Every time I say I am something I am not yet, I risk enjoying the title instead of earning it. The words 'I am a person who prays at night' can feel almost as good as praying at night. That is the trap.
The cure is small and unglamorous. Say less about what you will do. Say plainly what you have not done. A true sentence, even an embarrassing one, keeps the legs light. 'I have not started' is a sentence that can still get up and start.
Those who did not even come to explain
A grandmother is moving into a smaller flat. Her daughter posts in the family group: we need four people on Saturday morning to carry boxes. One cousin replies within the hour. He has his son's match, he is sorry, he will bring food in the evening. Another cousin reads the message. The two small ticks turn blue. He never replies at all.
The ayah has the same two figures in it. One group came. Wa-jāʾa al-muʿadhdhirūna: the excuse-makers came, asking to be given leave. Another group simply sat. They did not come, did not ask, did not explain.
The commentaries read the first group in two ways. Some early voices say they had real excuses and were people of genuine need. One major commentary prefers this reading for a simple reason. The ayah sets them apart from those who lied, so they were probably not liars. Others say the excuses were false and Allah did not accept them. The ayah's own wording holds both possibilities, and the commentators record both.
But on the second group there is no disagreement. They stayed behind without any excuse they cared to show. One commentary calls it boldness against the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. They did not think he was owed an explanation.
There is something here about how we treat people. An excuse, even a weak one, says: you matter enough for me to account to you. Silence says: you do not. Ignoring the request is not neutral. It is a message, and often the louder one.
Of course a flimsy excuse is not a virtue. But notice the ladder the ayah draws. One rung down from an honest yes is an honest no. One rung down from that is a dressed-up no. At the very bottom is no answer at all.
Which rung do you usually stand on? If you cannot come, come anyway to say so. Pick up the phone, write the message. Turning up to explain is already a small act of respect.
Token effort, built to produce an excuse
A student is set a hard chapter to read. She opens the book, reads two pages and closes it. The next day she tells her teacher she tried but could not follow it. Every word is true. She did try, for nine minutes. The trying was arranged so that the excuse would be honest.
The word in the ayah is al-muʿadhdhirūna. The commentaries give it two readings. In one, it is a softened form of 'those who make excuses', and an excuse can be true or false. In the other, it comes from taʿdhīr, falling short. The lexicons describe a man who does a thing without real effort. One commentary gives the everyday phrase: he stood up qiyām taʿdhīr. You asked him to handle a matter, and he only made a show of handling it. Another says the muʿadhdhir gives the impression he has an excuse when he has none.
The lexicons also open the word's deeper sense. An excuse, one says, is trying by speech to put right what you are blamed for. It takes three forms. You say you did not do it. You say why you did it. Or you say you did it and will not do it again. That third form is repentance. So every repentance is an excuse, but not every excuse is a repentance.
That sentence sorts a great deal. The token effort is a way of collecting the first two kinds of excuse in advance. I was there. I did my part. What it avoids is the third kind, the one that admits and changes.
The ayah's sharper reading catches a habit many of us have. We do just enough of a hard thing to be able to say we did it. We attend the first ten minutes of the class. We give the smallest donation that lets us say we gave. We start the fast of Monday and quietly let it drop by noon.
Allah is not deceived by a show of effort. The only person the show convinces is the one putting it on. If you are going to fall short, fall short honestly. Then the third kind of excuse is still open to you.
Coming for a signature, not for a reason
A young man wants to skip his cousin's nikah to attend a trade fair. He does not just stay away. He spends an evening searching, until he finds a post saying family events are optional. He sends a screenshot to his mother. He wanted more than freedom. He wanted it signed off.
The ayah says the excuse-makers came li-yuʾdhana lahum, so that they would be given leave. The verb is passive. Leave was to be granted to them, by someone else. They were not only choosing to stay. They wanted the staying approved, stamped and made official.
One commentary notices a telling detail. Those who were truly weak, ill or penniless had no need to ask at all. Their situation already spoke for them. The ones who came asking were precisely those whose case was not obvious.
There is a common instinct behind this. We often want permission more than we want the thing itself. A decision we already made feels lighter once someone else has said yes. The weight moves from our shoulders to theirs.
That is why people go looking for the one answer, among a hundred, that releases them. They ask the friend who always says yes. They search until the search agrees with them. The question is not 'what is right?' but 'who will let me?'
The ayah does not condemn asking. Asking was the Prophet's ﷺ open door, and some who came were sincere. But it invites a quiet check on our motives. When I ask for permission, do I want guidance, or do I want cover?
One way to tell the difference is to notice how you react to a 'no'. If a 'no' sends you straight to ask someone else, you were not asking. You were shopping. Better to bring the real reason, with your own name on it, and let it stand or fall.
A leader who does not beg the reluctant
A volunteer coordinator at a mosque is planning the Eid clean-up. One man on the list has said yes three years running and never come. This year, when he begins his apology, she smiles and says: no problem, we will manage. She does not plead or lecture. Two new teenagers take his place and do it better.
Letting a reluctant person go without pleading takes steadiness. The ayah is about people who asked to be excused from a campaign, and the answer they received.
The commentaries name some of the groups who came to the Prophet ﷺ asking to stay behind. Among the reports, one tribe said they had families to protect. If we march with you, they said, raiders will fall on our wives, children and herds. Another report says groups pleaded hardship and large households. The reports differ on who exactly they were.
One report, from an early Successor and carried without a chain, gives his reply in a single sentence. Allah has told me your news, and Allah will make me free of need of you. Other commentaries say only that he excused them.
Notice what he did not do. He did not argue the details of the excuse. He did not plead with them or shame them. He released them, and named where his real support came from.
This is a lesson leaders learn slowly. A mission built on reluctant people carries their reluctance into every task. Begging them to stay often costs more than letting them go. And a leader whose confidence rests on who turns up will panic every time someone does not.
His confidence rested elsewhere. That freed him to be gracious. He could accept the excuse at face value and leave its truth to Allah.
In a team, a family project or a community effort, the principle holds. Make the invitation clear and warm. Accept the 'no' without drama. Do not build your plan on those who have told you, in effect, they will not come. Then put your energy into the people who are still standing beside you.
'Among them': the threat that leaves a door
A careful reader may stop at the ayah's last sentence. A painful punishment for staying home from a journey? That sounds severe for a missed march.
Read the sentence slowly, though. The punishment is not promised to those who stayed. It is promised to alladhīna kafarū minhum, those who disbelieved among them. The fault named is disbelief, a claim of faith that had nothing behind it. Missing the road was a symptom, not the charge.
And the small word minhum, among them, matters. One commentary asks why it is there. His answer: Allah knew that some of these same people would later believe and escape the punishment. So the sentence was worded to cover only some. It does not close the file on the group.
The very next ayah makes the boundary plain. There is no blame on the weak, the sick or those with nothing to spend (9:91). The fault was never weakness. It was falsehood.
Think of a head teacher addressing a school assembly after a cheating scandal. She does not say: every final-year student is expelled. She says: those who knowingly cheated will face consequences; anyone who comes forward this week will be treated differently. The warning is real. It is also targeted, and it leaves a door ajar.
That is the shape of this sentence. It is stern because the lie was serious. The lie was told to Allah and His Messenger, about faith itself. Yet even here, in one of the hardest passages of the surah, the wording leaves room for those who would turn.
What remains open is whether we use that room. The door in minhum is not a loophole for others. It is an invitation to each reader to make sure the claim 'I believe' has something real under it, while there is still time.
A common misreading
Often heard: An excuse is always a lie dressed up.
Closer to the ayah: The commentaries read the excuse-makers in two ways: some with genuine need, some with false pleas. An excuse can be honest, and the highest kind, admitting and turning, is repentance itself.
Often heard: This ayah condemns desert people as such.
Closer to the ayah: It sorts them: some came with excuses, some sat without one, and only those who disbelieved among them are threatened. The next ayat lift blame from the honestly unable and, soon after, praise believers among the same people (9:99).
Words to know
ٱلْمُعَذِّرُونَ al-muʿadhdhirūna · the root ʿ-dh-r
The excuse-makers. The commentaries give two readings. It may be a softened form of 'those who offer excuses', true or false. Or it means those who fall short and only make a show of an excuse. Which group they were, and whether their excuses were genuine, is reported in more than one way.
وَقَعَدَ wa-qaʿada · the root q-ʿ-d
And there sat. The commentaries say these sat back from coming to the Prophet ﷺ at all, without offering any excuse. One writer on the heart cites the ayah to show that lying itself makes a person sit, holding him back from what would benefit him.
Questions to sit with
- Which plan have you described so often that describing it now feels like doing it?
- When you cannot help, which rung do you usually choose: an honest no, a dressed-up no, or silence?
- What permission are you hoping someone will give you so that the decision stops feeling like yours?
Live it today
Find one request you left unanswered this month and reply today, even if the answer is no. Then drop one 'I am about to start' from your speech until you have started.
Echoes in the Quran
- Surah Al-A'raf 7:164A real excuse is an account owed to the Lord, as those who kept warning had. Here some brought only a show of one.
- Surah At-Tawbah 9:99From the same desert come believers whose giving is a step towards Allah. No one is judged by where they live.
Come back to this ayah when you feel...
when you go looking for the answer you want · when you are tempted to lie · when you know what is right but keep putting it off · when you lead others
The classical tafsir of this ayah
Tafsir al-Jalalayn · Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) · Tafsir al-Tabari (abridged) · Tafsir al-Qurtubi (abridged) · Tafsir al-Sa'di
Read the whole surah
A proclamation at Mina, and the road home: a reflection on all of Surah At-Tawbah, from its first ayah to its last.
Ponder At-Tawbah 9:90 in the app →In the app: the Mushaf, every word with its root, side-by-side tafsir, and your own private reflections. Free, no account, works offline.