Surah Yunus, ayah 43 (10:43)
Surah Yunus · Makki · ayah 43 of 109 · in Stepping back, and the question 'when?'
Ponder Yunus 10:43 in the app →وَمِنْهُم مَّن يَنظُرُ إِلَيْكَ ۚ أَفَأَنتَ تَهْدِى ٱلْعُمْىَ وَلَوْ كَانُوا۟ لَا يُبْصِرُونَ
“And among them are those who look at you. But can you guide the blind although they will not [attempt to] see?”
Saheeh International
What does Surah Yunus 10:43 mean?
Some look straight at the Messenger and see nothing; no one can guide the blind when the heart's sight is gone as well.
Reflections
The blind are guided every day
A reader who is blind, or who loves someone who is, may wince at this ayah. Is blindness being used as a picture of disbelief? Does it suggest the blind cannot be guided?
Look at what the ayah actually says. A-fa-anta tahdī al-ʿumya wa-law kānū lā yubṣirūn: will you guide the blind, even if they do not see? A later commentator explains the second half. It means: even if, to the loss of eyesight, is added the loss of insight. The purpose of seeing, he says, is to take a lesson and to understand. The mainstay of that is insight. That is why a blind man with insight can perceive and grasp what a foolish man with sight misses.
So the ayah does not say the blind cannot be guided. They are guided every day. Picture an elderly pilgrim between Safa and Marwa. He lost his sight ten years ago. His hand rests on his son's shoulder, and he walks the seven laps without a stumble, reciting all the way. He is being guided, and he is willing to be. His heart is wide awake.
What cannot be done is to guide someone who has neither the eye nor the insight, and will not take the shoulder. That is the person the ayah describes: looking straight at the Messenger ﷺ, seeing nothing, and refusing the hand.
The Prophet ﷺ also gave the blind a promise, recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari. Allah said: if I test My servant through his two beloved ones and he is patient, I will give him Paradise in place of them. His two eyes were meant.
What remains open is the honest discomfort of the image. It is not about the blind. It is about the sighted who will not see.
One face, two kinds of looking
What did they see when they looked at him? A narration-based commentator lists it. His calm deliberateness. His dignified bearing. His great character. The clear signs of his prophethood, plain to people of insight and understanding.
The same commentator then makes a sharp observation. These people looked as others looked. But none of the guidance others received reached them. The believers looked at him with the eye of reverence. The deniers looked at him with the eye of contempt. He cites the Quran's record of what the scornful said on seeing him: is this the one Allah has sent as a messenger? (25:41).
One face. Two gazes. The difference was not in what was seen but in what the viewer brought.
Picture a new manager in her first week at a busy warehouse. She arrives early, listens a great deal, asks the night shift what is going wrong. Two employees watch her. One tells his wife that evening the new boss is humble; she actually listens. The other tells his friends she is weak; she does not even know what she is doing. Same week, same woman. Two verdicts.
Most of us have seen this in ourselves. What we expect shapes what we see. Contempt does not wait for evidence. It arrives first and arranges the evidence to fit.
The ayah asks something uncomfortable of the reader. When you look at people of faith, at scholars, at the Prophet's ﷺ example as it reaches you, which eye do you use? The eye of reverence sees what is there. The eye of contempt sees only what it came to find.
Seeing that follows the trail
Yubṣirūn, they see, comes from a root with two pictures side by side. The lexicons describe a newborn pup opening its eyes for the first time: plain sight. They also describe baṣīra as a trace of blood that shows a hunter where the wounded animal went. He follows it, reading what it means. Sight that sees, and sight that understands.
That second picture explains how the ayah can say that people who look still do not see. They had eyes, and they turned them towards the Messenger ﷺ. What they lacked was the hunter's reading of the trail. They saw the marks and did not follow them anywhere.
The concise modern commentaries say it plainly. They looked with their outward eyes, not with their insight. One adds that they looked at him and at the proofs of his prophethood. They did not see the light of faith Allah had given him.
Picture a grandmother sitting by her front window. Her grandson comes up the path after his exam results. He is smiling, he waves, he says it went fine. Everyone else in the house believes him. She sees the way he holds his bag and how fast he climbs the stairs. Before he reaches his room she has put the kettle on and found the biscuits. She read the trail.
The Quran asks for that kind of seeing. The signs of Allah are not hidden. They are in the sky, in our own bodies, in the life of His Messenger ﷺ. Most of us look at them daily.
The question is whether we follow the trail. Choose one sign you see every day, and ask where it leads.
The sighted who looked, and the blind man who came
The concise commentary reaches for another verse to explain this one. It is not the eyes that go blind, but the hearts in the breasts (22:46). Another Makkan surah gives a picture of the same truth turned inside out.
In ʿAbasa, the Prophet ﷺ is with leading men of Quraysh, hoping they will believe. They can see him perfectly well. A blind man comes, asking to be taught. The Quran records that he came striving, and in awe (80:8-9). He could not see the Messenger ﷺ at all. Yet he was the one who came to be guided.
Set the two passages beside each other. In Yunus, people look straight at the Prophet ﷺ and see nothing. In ʿAbasa, a man who cannot look at him sees exactly who he is, and walks towards him.
The two scenes together dismantle an assumption. We tend to think that being close to the evidence makes faith easy. If only I had lived then, if only I had seen him. The Quraysh had seen him for forty years. Many of them never believed. A man who never saw his face was among the first to run to him.
Picture a young man who grew up next door to the mosque. He has heard the call to prayer five times a day his whole life. He walks past the door every morning. A convert who moved to the city last year, who found the mosque on a map, is inside before he is.
Nearness to the light is a gift. It is not the same as seeing by it. Ask what you have been looking at for years without coming towards it.
Give eyes, not only directions
A-fa-anta tahdī: will you guide? A narration-based commentator paraphrases the question. Can you create sight for the blind, so that they find their way by it? You cannot, and no one can but Allah. So you cannot show them the road of right guidance either. That is in My hand.
The ayah is about something only Allah gives. But it holds a lesson for anyone who leads people at a human scale. Directions are useless to someone who cannot see. And sight, in the human sense of understanding, is something good leaders try to build, not just assume.
Picture a finance director with a new junior analyst. Each week the young man brings her deals to approve, and she tells him yes or no. After three months he still cannot tell a good deal from a bad one. He has had ninety directions and no eyes. She changes her approach. For a month she sits with him and walks through each deal: what she looks at first, what worries her, why. By spring he is spotting problems she missed.
The ayah describes the limit: some people cannot be given sight by any human being. It is Allah who opens hearts. But within that limit, a parent, teacher or manager can do more than issue instructions. They can explain the reasons, show the signs, and help the other person learn to see for himself.
This is how the Quran itself teaches. It rarely gives a command without pointing to a sign: the sky, the rain, the ship, the field. It trains the eye, then asks for the step.
Next time you guide someone, ask yourself whether you are only telling them where to go, or helping them see.
Looking at him through a screen
Yanẓuru ilayka: he looks at you. A legal commentator explains that it means he keeps looking: a gaze held for a long time. He compares the ayah describing frightened men whose eyes roll as they stare (33:19). These were not glances. They were long looks, and still nothing was seen.
We cannot look at the Prophet ﷺ as they did. But we look at him in other ways. Biographies, lectures, quotes on social media, illustrated timelines of his campaigns. Many of us have spent hours looking.
Picture a woman whose phone lock screen has shown the green dome over the Prophet's ﷺ mosque for six years. She looks at it fifty times a day, with real love. One evening her son asks what the Prophet ﷺ used to do when he was angry. She opens her mouth, and realises she does not know.
The ayah's lookers had something we lack: the man himself in front of them. They had something we share: the ability to look a long time and see nothing that changes them.
A narration-based commentator says what they looked at: his gentleness, his bearing, his character. Those are exactly the things meant to be copied, not only admired. The Quran calls him a beautiful example for whoever hopes in Allah and the Last Day (33:21).
So the honest test of our looking is what it produces. Pick one small habit of the Prophet ﷺ from what you have read or heard. Let your next look at his life end in one action you can take tomorrow. Then you will have seen him, not only looked.
A common misreading
Often heard: The ayah suggests blind people cannot be guided.
Closer to the ayah: One commentator explains that the blindness meant is lack of sight joined to lack of insight. A blind person with insight perceives what a foolish sighted person misses.
Often heard: Seeing is a matter of the eyes.
Closer to the ayah: The root pairs plain sight with baṣīra, the hunter's reading of a blood trail. Seeing, in the Quran's sense, means following what you see to where it leads.
Words to know
يُبْصِرُونَ yubṣirūna · the root b-ṣ-r
They see. One later commentator reads the clause as insight added to eyesight: the point of seeing is to take a lesson. That resolves how people can be said to look and yet not see.
تَهْدِى tahdī · the root h-d-y
You guide. A narration-based commentator glosses the question as: can you give the blind sight to find their way? Guiding them to the road of right guidance belongs to Allah alone.
يَنظُرُ yanẓuru · the root n-ẓ-r
He looks. A legal commentator says it means one who keeps his gaze on you. The singular verb, after the plural 'they listen' in the previous ayah, follows the word 'man' rather than its sense.
Questions to sit with
- When you look at people of faith, which eye do you bring: reverence or contempt?
- What sign have you been looking at for years without following where it leads?
- Which habit of the Prophet ﷺ could your next reading of his life turn into an action?
Live it today
Choose one small habit of the Prophet ﷺ you already know about, such as smiling at people or beginning with the right. Practise it deliberately for a week.
Echoes in the Quran
- Surah 'Abasa 80:8The leading men could see him perfectly. A blind man came striving to be taught, and he was the one who saw.
- Surah Al-Hajj 22:46Al-Hajj names this blindness: it is not the eyes that go blind, but the hearts within the chests.
- Surah Al-Furqan 25:41Al-Furqan records what such looking produced: is this the one Allah has sent as a messenger?
Come back to this ayah when you feel...
when you send blessings on the Prophet · when you expect someone you admire to be more than human · when you are tempted to judge · when you lead others
This ayah and other verses on the same subject
The classical tafsir of this ayah
Tafsir al-Jalalayn · Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) · Tafsir al-Tabari (abridged) · Tafsir al-Qurtubi (abridged) · Tafsir al-Sa'di
Read the whole surah
The board that holds your whole weight: a reflection on all of Surah Yunus, from its first ayah to its last.
Ponder Yunus 10:43 in the app →In the app: the Mushaf, every word with its root, side-by-side tafsir, and your own private reflections. Free, no account, works offline.