Surah At-Tawbah, ayah 96 (9:96)
Surah At-Tawbah · Madani · ayah 96 of 129 · in The excused and the excuse-makers
Ponder At-Tawbah 9:96 in the app →يَحْلِفُونَ لَكُمْ لِتَرْضَوْا۟ عَنْهُمْ ۖ فَإِن تَرْضَوْا۟ عَنْهُمْ فَإِنَّ ٱللَّهَ لَا يَرْضَىٰ عَنِ ٱلْقَوْمِ ٱلْفَـٰسِقِينَ
“They swear to you so that you might be satisfied with them. But if you should be satisfied with them - indeed, Allāh is not satisfied with a defiantly disobedient people.”
Saheeh International
What does Surah At-Tawbah 9:96 mean?
They swore to win your approval; but approval bought with oaths changes nothing if Allah is not pleased.
Reflections
Not content to be let off, they wanted to be liked
A man misses the whole week of preparations for his sister's wedding. He was busy, he says. On the day, he apologises. She tells him it is fine. But he does not stop there. He wants her to say she understands, that he is still the best brother, that it does not matter. By the evening, she is comforting him for having let her down.
Read this ayah beside the one before it. In 9:95 the hypocrites swore li-tuʿriḍū ʿanhum, so that you would turn away and leave them unreproached. Here they swear li-tarḍaw ʿanhum, so that you would be pleased with them.
One commentary draws the line between the two. After saying they swore so that the believers would stop troubling them, Allah shows they also swore to be approved. The first oath asked to escape blame. The second asked for something more: warmth, endorsement, a clean name.
That is a familiar human appetite. It is rarely enough for us to be forgiven. We want to be thought well of, too. We want the person we failed to reassure us. We want the matter not only dropped but rewritten in our favour.
The ayah does not let the hypocrites have the second wish. But the mirror it holds up is for us. How often, after letting someone down, do we push past an apology into a request for comfort? How often does 'I am sorry' quietly become 'tell me I am still good'?
Real repentance asks for less. It admits the fault and leaves the other person free to feel what they feel. It does not demand to be liked.
Next time you apologise, stop after the apology. Do not fish for reassurance. Let your changed behaviour, over time, earn back the warmth. That warmth will mean more because you did not swear for it.
Five stars on an empty box
A seller online has thousands of glowing reviews. Five stars, again and again. A woman orders a supposedly genuine perfume. It arrives in perfect packaging and smells of nothing much. She checks the reviews again. Every one of them is still there, still glowing. None of them has changed what is in the bottle.
The ayah's second half has the same logic. Fa-in tarḍaw ʿanhum fa-inna Allāha lā yarḍā ʿan al-qawmi al-fāsiqīn: if you are pleased with them, Allah is not pleased with the defiantly disobedient.
One commentary explains the point plainly. If you believers are pleased with them and accept their excuses, your pleasure will not benefit them with Allah. He knows their hidden affairs that you do not know. Another puts it in one line. No one's pleasure has any effect alongside His displeasure.
We live in an economy of approval. Likes, followers, testimonials, references, the nod of the right person in the right room. It is easy to treat these as if they settle questions of worth. If enough people approve, surely it must be good.
The ayah cuts the cord between human approval and real standing. People can be pleased with you for years, and the reality inside you can stay exactly the same. Reviews do not change the contents of the bottle.
This is a sobering thought, and also a freeing one. Sobering, because a good reputation is not a guarantee of anything. Freeing, because a bad reputation, unjustly given, does not change your standing with Allah either.
So the question worth asking is not what people think of you. It is what is in the bottle. Spend less energy managing the reviews. Spend more on the contents. Pray in private as you would in public. Give where no one will hear of it. Let the One whose pleasure counts be the audience you work for.
If you were fooled, and what the ayah says about it
A woman lends a large sum to a cousin who tells a moving story about medical bills. Months later she learns there were no bills. She feels foolish more than robbed. How could I not see it? she keeps asking. Everyone else seems to have known.
The ayah says: fa-in tarḍaw ʿanhum, if you are pleased with them. It allows that the believers might be won over by the oaths. The commentaries read the sentence in two ways, and both are worth hearing.
One reading is gentle. If you are pleased with them, it says, that is because you do not know their truth from their lies. Your pleasure is understandable. It simply does not change their standing with Allah. A concise modern commentary agrees: you may be pleased because you cannot see their lying.
The other reading is a warning. Several commentaries take the sentence as a prohibition in its strongest form. Do not be pleased with them, for that would set your will against your Lord's. Being pleased with someone Allah is not pleased with, one says, is not a small thing.
The two readings belong together. The first comforts those who were deceived in good faith. You are not blamed for being unable to see into a heart. Your trust was not your sin. The second guards against something different. Once the truth is clear, do not go on approving what you now know to be false.
For the woman with the empty account, the first reading is the one she needs today. She acted with kindness on what she could see. The deception belongs to the one who deceived. Allah knows both hearts.
And the second reading tells her what comes next. She need not keep pretending, or lend again to the same story. She can forgive without being naive. Trust given in good faith is never wasted with Allah, even when people waste it.
An oath aimed at the audience
A builder is quoting for a kitchen. He mentions that he never misses Jumuʿa. He quotes a hadith about honesty in trade. He swears that his prices are the lowest in the area. The family is impressed and signs. Later they discover the invoice is padded by a third.
Notice two words in this ayah: yaḥlifūna lakum, they swear to you. The oath is aimed at people. Its purpose is stated straight after: li-tarḍaw ʿanhum, so that you will be pleased with them.
The commentaries say the oaths were sworn by Allah, to confirm their false excuses. The name of Allah was in their mouths. But the one whose pleasure they were seeking was the listener. Allah was invoked as a witness. He was not the one they wanted to please.
That is a quiet distortion that can creep into anyone's religion. Pious words used for a human audience. A hadith quoted to win an argument, not to obey it. A 'mashaAllah' to seem humble, a 'wallahi' to close a sale. The vocabulary is sacred. The aim is human approval.
The whole surah keeps peeling back the layer between what is said and what is meant. Here it shows how the holiest word can be turned into a tool, pointed at the people in the room.
The test for ourselves is simple to state. When I use the name of Allah, who am I trying to reach? Am I speaking to Him, or using Him to speak to them?
A practical step: notice your religious phrases for one day. Each 'wallahi', each quoted verse, each pious aside. Ask quietly who it was for. Keep the ones that were for Him. Let the others go. Your speech will become plainer, and your oaths will carry more weight when you truly need them.
When your approval becomes someone else's certificate
The chair of a mosque committee is approached by a man raising money for a cause overseas. The man is charming and swears the appeal is genuine. The chair, moved, lets him speak after Jumuʿa and stands beside him. Hundreds give, because the chair stood there. Later the appeal proves false. The money is gone, and so is some of the trust people placed in the chair.
The ayah addresses the believers as a body. Fa-in tarḍaw ʿanhum: if you, plural, are pleased with them. One commentary notes the danger behind such pleasure. If some believers accepted the excuses, the hypocrites would be encouraged. Then they might hope the rest, and even the Prophet ﷺ, would follow.
That is exactly how approval works in a community. It spreads. The pleasure of a respected person becomes a certificate that others trust without checking. A leader's warmth is never private. It tells everyone watching: this person is safe.
That is why the ayah sets a limit on that warmth. However sincere the oath sounds, approval that runs against the truth is not a kindness. It lends your name to something your name cannot cover.
For anyone in a position of trust, a parent, a teacher, an imam, a manager, the lesson is careful, not cold. You can be kind to a person without endorsing their claim. You can listen, help, even forgive, without standing beside them on the platform.
Before you give public approval, ask what evidence you have beyond the oath. Ask who will rely on your approval and what it might cost them. A moment's caution protects many people who will never know you hesitated.
And if you are fooled despite your care, the previous lesson holds. Admit it openly, repair what you can, and let people see that your approval follows the truth when the truth becomes clear.
Is Allah's displeasure a mood?
A reader may ask a fair question. 'Allah is not pleased with them' sounds very human, like someone in a sulk. Does God have moods? And if He is displeased with people, does that mean He has written them off?
Look at the exact wording. The ayah does not say 'Allah is not pleased with them'. It says He is not pleased with al-qawmi al-fāsiqīn, the people who are defiantly disobedient. One commentary notes the choice. A description is used where a simple 'them' would have done. The aim, he says, is to record against them the quality that earned the verdict: leaving obedience.
That changes the picture. The verdict attaches to a quality, not to a temper. It is not a mood triggered by a slight. It is a settled judgement on a chosen state.
A concise modern commentary adds who falls under it. Allah is not pleased with these, or with anyone else, who persist in leaving the obedience of Allah and His Messenger. The key word is persist. A quality can be left. Many who once stood among the disobedient later turned, and the Quran honours them.
Think of a university that will not grant a degree to a student who submits plagiarised work. The refusal is not personal anger. It is a stable standard applied to an act. The same student, writing honestly next year, can graduate with distinction.
The ayah's wording keeps that door open. Displeasure is tied to a description. Change the description, and the verdict has nothing left to rest on.
What remains open is personal. Which of my habits would earn that description if they hardened into a settled way of life? The ayah does not invite us to fear Allah's moods. It invites us to watch our own direction, while the description can still be changed.
A common misreading
Often heard: If enough people are pleased with me, Allah must be pleased too.
Closer to the ayah: The ayah separates the two: human approval, even the believers', does not benefit anyone with Allah if He is not pleased. Reviews do not change what is in the bottle.
Words to know
لِتَرْضَوْا۟ li-tarḍaw · the root r-ḍ-w
So that you would be pleased. The commentaries say they swore to be approved and kept in the believers' good graces. Some read what follows as comfort, others as a strong prohibition on being pleased with them.
ٱلْفَـٰسِقِينَ al-fāsiqīna · the root f-s-q
The defiantly disobedient, those who leave obedience. One commentary notes the description is used instead of 'them' to record the quality that earned the verdict.
Questions to sit with
- After you apologise, how often do you push on to ask for reassurance?
- Whose approval do you work hardest for, and how much of your inner life does it actually see?
- When you use the name of Allah in conversation, who are you really speaking to?
Live it today
For one day, notice each religious phrase you use and ask who it was for. When you next apologise, stop after the apology and ask for nothing more.
Echoes in the Quran
Come back to this ayah when you feel...
when you worry what others will think · when you have wronged someone · when someone praises you · when you want to be admired
The classical tafsir of this ayah
Tafsir al-Jalalayn · Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) · Tafsir al-Tabari (abridged) · Tafsir al-Qurtubi (abridged) · Tafsir al-Sa'di
Read the whole surah
A proclamation at Mina, and the road home: a reflection on all of Surah At-Tawbah, from its first ayah to its last.
Ponder At-Tawbah 9:96 in the app →In the app: the Mushaf, every word with its root, side-by-side tafsir, and your own private reflections. Free, no account, works offline.